Appearance
Mellita tenuis has a horizontally flattened test, similar to other species of sand dollars. The sand dollar can grow up to 15 cm in diameter. Symmetrically across the test are five holes called lunules, four of which are ambulacral and line up with the petals, and one of which is interambulacral and between two petals. The central lunule is a characteristic shared with other keyhole sand dollars in the genus. The outer tissue of the sand dollar is often gray, green, tan, or brown.
The genus Mellita contains multiple cryptic species, making it difficult to distinguish M. tenuis from other species of keyhole sand dollars.

