This nudibranch prefers to feed on tunicates (such as the sessile ascidians), but overall has a diverse diet, also consuming hydroids, anthozoans, crustaceans, other nudibranchs, dead animals, and the polyps of jellyfish (theoretically, they may also consume stranded adult jellyfish too, if accessible). One study theorizes that H. crassicornis prefers tunicates and feeds only minimally on cnidarians (such as hydroids) either just to obtain defensive nematocysts in complement to their main diet, because cnidarians are simply too toxic to consume in large quantities, or simply because tunicates are nutritionally superior. It sometimes attacks other nudibranchs, and will even cannibalize smaller specimens of its own species.