Appearance
This species can reach a maximum length of 5.1 centimetres (2.0 in) in males. The valves are black with an intermittent white stripe that runs dorsally. The girdle is granular and is composed of bristles that are a "reddish-brown" color.
This species is said to be morphologically similar to two other Nuttallina species in California – N. fluxa (Carpenter, 1864) and a studied but undescribed third species (Piper, 1984), and are difficult to distinguish without genetic analyses. Some authors question whether they are even distinct species.

